To earn SUNYAC XC Championship Hall of Fame status a runner must finish in the top-five once, top-ten twice, or top-15 three times throughout their running career at the conference meet.
| Year | Name | School |
| 1963 | Mike Best | Buffalo State |
| Tim Burns | Buffalo State | |
| Roger Hauck | Buffalo State | |
| Bob Lalley | Cortland | |
| Ralph Manners | Plattsburgh | |
| 1964 | Bob Fitts | Cortland |
| Dennis Fries | Cortland | |
| George Schilling | Brockport | |
| Gary Westerfield | Brockport | |
| 1965 | Wayne Rose | Buffalo State |
| Todd Soeder | Oswego | |
| Ron White | Brockport | |
| 1966 | Jim Denver | Oneonta |
| Mike Donnelly | Oswego | |
| Don Soloman | Oswego | |
| 1967 | Murray Banks | Cortland |
| Ed Faulkner | Cortland | |
| Ron Fleury | Cortland | |
| Al Pastore | Oneonta | |
| Al Rudland | Buffalo State | |
| Dave Tresholavy | Brockport | |
| 1968 | Bob Goodell | Brockport |
| Rod Williams | Brockport | |
| 1969 | Thomas Nasal | Buffalo State |
| Brian Pelky | Potsdam | |
| Don Pollack | Buffalo State | |
| Mark Ryerson | Buffalo State | |
| Bill Young | Oneonta | |
| 1970 | Phil Bonfiglio | Cortland |
| Thomas Burkiewicz | Fredonia | |
| Gene Foster | Oneonta | |
| Chris Weber | Brockport | |
| 1971 | Scott Abercrombie | Albany |
| Bill Fox | Fredonia | |
| Dennis Hackett | Albany | |
| Brian Quinn | Albany | |
| Fran Verdoliva | Oswego | |
| 1972 | Doug Colton | Geneseo |
| Joe Contario | Geneseo | |
| Robin Goodrich | Plattsburgh | |
| George Pfeiffer | Cortland | |
| Vinny Reda | Albany | |
| Jim Schraeder | Albany | |
| 1973 | Carlo Cherubino | Albany |
| Glen Pasier | Fredonia | |
| Fred Suarez | Oswego | |
| 1974 | Charles Clark | Fredonia |
| Brian Dodge | Plattsburgh | |
| Daniel Parker | Geneseo | |
| Bruce Teague | Plattsburgh | |
| 1975 | Willie Bauza | Geneseo |
| Robert Daniels | Binghamton | |
| John Evans | Plattsburgh | |
| 1976 | Chris Burns | Albany |
| Robert Carroll | Fredonia | |
| Bill Martin | Brockport | |
| Bill Orlando | Oswego | |
| Rich Saxton | Brockport | |
| Mark Shinkle | Brockport | |
| 1977 | Jack Callaci | Oneonta |
| Al Diovanni | Plattsburgh | |
| John Luther | Binghamton | |
| William Mathis | Albany | |
| 1978 | James Hallgreen | Fredonia |
| Dan McCormack | Brockport | |
| Richard Neary | Fredonia | |
| Robert Russel | Plattsburgh | |
| 1979 | Joe Bianco | Geneseo |
| Neil Moore | Fredonia | |
| Mark Raybuck | Binghamton | |
| 1980 | Albert Anson | Univ. Buffalo |
| Don Brenner | Fredonia | |
| Scott Jamens | Abany | |
| Bernie Prabucki | Fredonia | |
| Kent Simon | Cortland | |
| Kim Vandermolen | Cortland | |
| 1981 | Paul Caoplino | Binghamton |
| James Sieckman | Fredonia | |
| 1982 | Dave Champagne | Plattsburgh |
| Richard Fett | Fredonia | |
| Kurt Kroemer | Binghamton | |
| Bruce Shapiro | Albany | |
| 1983 | Mark Cohen | Oswego |
| Gary Fancher | Oswego | |
| Mike Hallinan | Brockport | |
| Arthur MacArthur | Fredonia | |
| 1984 | Jeff Bryk | Buffalo State |
| Ian Clements | Albany | |
| Dean Diltz | Plattsburgh | |
| Michael Gaughran | Fredonia | |
| Edward McGill | Albany | |
| 1985 | Darryl Dawson | Cortland |
| Vincent Gugino | Fredonia | |
| Scot Slade | Buffalo State | |
| Josh Stiner | Cortland | |
| 1986 | Peter Gorden | Cortland |
| Mike Gravelle | Geneseo | |
| Timothy Hoff | Albany | |
| Steve Stell Wagen | Geneseo | |
| 1987 | John Countway | Fredonia |
| Joe Kearny | Cortland | |
| Pete Knowlton | Geneseo | |
| John Waldron | Cortlnd | |
| 1988 | Mark Howland | Fredonia |
| Leonard Plunkett | Fredonia | |
| John Trowse | Brockport | |
| 1989 | Mike Garger | Geneseo |
| Art Gunther | Binghamton | |
| Tim Kelly | Oneonta | |
| Seth Lane | Binghamton | |
| 1990 | Todd Grady | Fredonia |
| Steve Perrigo | Fredonia | |
| Greg Potter | Cortland | |
| Mark Thompson | Cortland | |
| 1991 | Pat Cauley | Cortland |
| Sean Downey | Fredonia | |
| Jason Porter | Cortland | |
| Andy Roblyer | Cortland | |
| Jeff Winden | Fredonia | |
| 1992 | Ben Carey | Cortland |
| 1993 | Justin Conover | Cortland |
| Joshua Reid | Fredonia | |
| Leon Scott | Geneseo | |
| Jim Sullivan | Binghamton | |
| 1994 | Jeremy Burt | Plattsburgh |
| Tim Eagan | Cortland | |
| Ken McPherson | Binghamton | |
| Tom Oullette | Plattsburgh | |
| 1995 | Matt Annabel | Geneseo |
| Todd Bauer | Brockport | |
| Gary Donahue | Geneseo | |
| Mary Kuss | Plattsburgh | |
| Stephen Wefer | Plattsburgh | |
| 1996 | Connaire Foran | Cortland |
| Mike Kent | Binghamton | |
| Teague Ruder | Geneseo | |
| 1997 | Corey Davidson | Plattsburgh |
| Walter Long | Plattsburgh | |
| Ted Powers | Brockport | |
| Tim Reetz | Fredonia | |
| Paul Salamone | Fredonia | |
| 1998 | Frank Bogdan | Buffalo State |
| Mike Heitzenrater | Cortland | |
| Grant Reynolds | Cortland | |
| Jerimie Slick | Cortland | |
| 1999 | Dan Courtney | Cortland |
| Jeremy Drowne | Plattsburgh | |
| Vinnue DeRocco | Fredonia | |
| Andy Miller | Fredonia | |
| 2000 | John Kennedy | Geneseo |
| David Bradshaw | Cortland | |
| Tony Gallo | Geneseo | |
| Rich Friedrich | Oswego | |
| Phil Goodwin | New Paltz | |
| Joe Oliver | Cortland | |
| 2001 | Matt Mills | Geneseo |
| Matt Drown | Plattsburgh | |
| Jay Wells | Plattsburgh | |
| Aaron Robertson | Potsdam | |
| 2002 | Jon Beck | Geneseo |
| James Sweeney | Fredonia | |
| Dave Bolen | Brockport | |
| Jason Walsh | Buffalo State | |
| 2003 | Ted Turner | Geneseo |
| Jeff Beck | Geneseo | |
| Matt Young | Geneseo | |
| Jason Casey | Geneseo | |
| Ross Huncovic | Geneseo | |
| Scott Austin | Brockport | |
| Paul Widjeskog | Plattsburgh | |
| 2004 | Matt Deshane | Plattsburgh |
| Fred Joslyn | Cortland | |
| Andy Cloke | Cortland | |
| 2005 | Ryan Kolb | Brockport |
| Shamus Nally | Cortland | |
| Dan Moore | Geneseo | |
| Mike McGrath | Geneseo | |
| Jim Tillapaugh | Geneseo | |
| 2006 | Nate Lockett | Geneseo |
| Jerry Greenlaw | Cortland | |
| 2007 | Seth Dubois | Cortland |
| Josh Henry | Cortland | |
| Justin Wager | Cortland | |
| Will Haskell | Geneseo | |
| 2008 | Tom Williams | Fredonia |
| Mike Heymann | Plattsburgh | |
| Travis De Russon | Cortland | |
| Brett Dolan | Geneseo | |
| Kyle O'Brien | Cortland | |
| 2009 | Tim Chichester | Geneseo |
| Lee Berube | Geneseo | |
| Bobby Henchen | Geneseo | |
| 2010 | Ryan O'Connor | Geneseo |
| Eddie Novara | Geneseo | |
| Matt Avery | Brockport | |
| 2011 | Mark Streb | Geneseo |
| Tom Clark | Geneseo | |
| Nick Marcantonio | Cortland | |
| 2012 | Alex Brimstein | Geneseo |
| Cody Mateer | Geneseo | |
| Cody Amengual | Cortland | |
| Ryan Moynihan | Geneseo | |
| 2013 | Casey Austin | Cortland |
| Cohen Miles-Rath | Geneseo | |
| Pat Fannon | Cortland | |
| Tim Lee | Cortland | |
| Jarred Iacovello | Cortland | |
| 2014 | Gary Messina | Brockport |
| Mike Scher | New Paltz | |
| Mitch Ryan | Cortland | |
| Zakk Hess | Fredonia | |
| Brendan Wortner | Geneseo | |
| 2015 | Isaac Garcia-Cassani | Geneseo |
| Afredo Mazzuca | Geneseo | |
| Kyle Collins | Fredonia | |
| Anthony Lupia | Oneonta | |
| 2016 | Alex Kramer | Geneseo |
| David Busby | Oneonta | |
| 2017 | Devin Akerley | Oneonta |
| Alex Burkes | Geneseo | |
| Ethan Francis | Fredonia | |
| Colin Greensiech | Oswego | |
| Dylan McCarthy | Oswego | |
| Connor Pulvidente | Geneseo | |
| 2018 | Sean McAneny | Geneseo |
| Jackson Tate | Geneseo | |
| Bradley Farnham | Geneseo | |
| Sean Welch | Geneseo | |
| Ethan McDonald | Oneonta | |
| 2019 | Sean Kuehn | Brockport |
| Luke Holtzman | Geneseo | |
| Lucas Sutton | Geneseo | |
| Riley Grossman | Geneseo | |
| Justin Hoelzl | Geneseo | |
| 2020 | Cancelled due to COVID-19 | |
| 2021 | Ezra Ruggles | Geneseo |
| Nick Andrews | Geneseo | |
| Michael Verde | Cortland | |
| Ryan Cory | Cortland | |
| 2022 | William Hall | Geneseo |
| Alex Hillyard | Geneseo | |
| Paul Suflita | Brockport | |
| Jonathan Zavala | Brockport | |
| 2023 | Austin Schoen | Geneseo |
| Hunter Brignall | Cortland | |
| Jared Smith | Brockport | |
| Charlie Wilson | Geneseo | |
| Nick Bauman | Geneseo |