| Year | Team Champion - Coach |
| 1978 | *Cortland - Chuck Winters |
| 1979 | Cortland - Chuck Winters |
| 1980 | Cortland - Chuck Winters |
| 1981 | Cortland - Chuck Winters |
| 1982 | Geneseo - Tony Diange |
| 1983 | Cortland - Chuck Winters |
| 1984 | Cortland - Jerry Casciani |
| 1985 | Cortland - Jerry Casciani |
| 1986 | Cortland - Jerry Casciani |
| 1987 | Cortland - Jerry Casciani |
| 1988-1999 | Terminated |
| 2000 | Cortland - Mike Pounds |
| 2001 | Cortland - Lelan Rogers |
| 2002 | Cortland - Lelan Rogers |
| 2003 | Cortland - Lelan Rogers |
| 2004 | Geneseo - Jim Lyons |
| 2005 | Cortland - Lelan Rogers |
| 2006 | Cortland - Rich Barnes |
| 2007 | Geneseo - Jim Lyons |
| 2008 | Cortland - Steve Beville |
| 2009 | Cortland - Steve Beville |
| 2010 | Cortland - Steve Beville |
| 2011 | Cortland - Steve Beville |
| 2012 | Cortland - Steve Beville |
| 2013 | Cortland - Steve Beville |
| 2014 | Cortland - Steve Beville |
| 2015 | Cortland - Steve Beville |
| 2016 | Cortland - Steve Beville |
*First year awarded
| Team | # of Titles |
| Brockport | 0 |
| Cortland | 25 |
| Geneseo | 3 |
| Oneonta | 0 |
| Oswego | 0 |
| Plattsburgh | 0 |
| Potsdam | 0 |