| Event | Athlete (School) | Date | Record |
| Shot Put | Dan Mlodzeniac (Fredonia) | 1983 | 17.64m |
| Long Jump | Shevaughn Allen (Buffalo State) | 2023 | 7.52m |
| Triple Jump | Shevaughn Allen (Buffalo State) | 2023 | 15.66m |
| High Jump | Kym Orr (Fredonia) | 1985 | 2.24m |
| Pole Vault | Joe Weaver (Brockport) | 2019 | 5.07m |
| Hammer | Pat Weinert (Oneonta) | 2015 | 64.49m* |
| Discus | Darius Favors (Brockport) | 2015 | 54.94m |
| Javelin | Gary Fisher (Cortland) | 1978 | 64.44m |
| Javelin (new) | Ken Ciolek (Brockport) | 2007 | 64.16m |
| 100m Dash | Daryl Brownlee (Buffalo State) | 1986 | 10.30 |
| 200m Dash | Sean Bernstein (Oneonta) | 2012 | 20.80* |
| 400m Dash | Justin Muise (Buffalo State) | 2003 | 47.06 |
| 800m Run | Nick Guarino (Fredonia) | 2011 | 1:49.12 |
| 1500m Run | Isaac Garcia-Cassani (Geneseo) | 2017 | 3:42.66 |
| Steeplechase | Cody Amengual (Cortland) | 2013 | 8:57.54 |
| 5000m Run | Nick Andrews (Geneseo) | 2022 | 14:11.44 |
| 10,000m Run | Eddie Novara (Geneseo) | 2012 | 29:32.75 |
| 110m Hurdles | Jeff York (Albany) | 1992 | 13.84 |
| 400m Hurdles | Lance Jensen (Geneseo) | 2023 | 50.63 |
| 4x100m Relay | CORTLAND | 2007 | 40.59 |
| K. Ma, J. Riese, M. Bieringer, A. Siddeeq | |||
| 4x400m Relay | BUFFALO STATE | 1983 | 3:10.99 |
| N. Hall, T. Tolli, W. Woodburn, E. Harris | |||
| 4x800m Relay | GENESEO | 2022 | 7:35.67 |
| Ezra Ruggles, Josh Goldberg, Alec Andrews, Nick Andrews | |||
| Decathlon | Jack Flood (Cortland) | 2017 | 7021 pts |
| Decathlon (old) | Mark Lineweaver (Brockport) | 1975 | 7101 pts* |
*This time or distance won first place at the NCAA Division III national meet.