| Year | Offensive Player of the Year | Defensive Player of the Year | Rookie of the Year | Coach of the Year | Tournament MVP |
| 1997 | Kim Pace (Oswego) | Shawn Keil (Oswego) | |||
| 1998 | Kristin Dimarzo (Cortland) | Tracey Davis (Oneonta) | |||
| 1999 | Kristin Dimarzo (Cortland) | Suzanne Behme (Geneseo) | |||
| 2000 | Jeanna Angotti (Cortland) | Cynthia Wetmore (Cortland) | |||
| 2001 | Brooke VandeWalker (Cortland) | Tony Zostant (Brockport) | |||
| 2002 | Brooke VandeWalker (Cortland) | Kim Powell (Oneonta) Katie Carbonaro (Oswego) |
Liz Monte (Geneseo) | ||
| 2003 | Sara Gorman (Cortland) | Regina Grosso (Cortland) | Laura Moan (Oneonta) | ||
| 2004 | Sara Gorman (Cortland) | Jennifer Willis (Cortland) Erin Maybeck (Oneonta) |
Megan Stevens (Buffalo St) | Sara Gorman (Cortland) | |
| 2005 | Kathryn Carbanaro (Oswego) | Keli Martin (Brockport) | Adair Stevens (Oswego) | Regina Grosso (Cortland) | |
| 2006 | Jennifer Willis (Cortland) | Alisha Schaad (Potsdam) | Cynthia Wetmore (Cortland) | Michelle Zimmer (Cortland) | |
| 2007 | Allison Bourgal (Cortland) | Lexie Goodhart (Brockport) | Traci Lian (Brockport) | Deanne Abell (Cortland) | |
| 2008 | Jessie Fritz (Cortland) Emily Reichert (Fredonia) |
Kelsey Lamb (Fredonia) | Chris Case (Fredonia) | Danielle Torre (Cortland) | |
| 2009 | Danielle Torre (Cortland) | Karen Shaddock (Buffalo St.) | Megan Stevens (Buffalo St) | Lindsay Abbott (Cortland) | |
| 2010 | Karen Shaddock (Buffalo St.) | Maria DeFato (Cortland) | Linda Michele (Brockport) | Maria DiFato (Cortland) | |
| 2011 | Lindsay Abbott (Cortland) | Caroline Buonocore (Geneseo) | Kathy Taylor (Cortland) | Mary Hartzheim (Cortland) | |
| 2012 | Lindsay Abbott (Cortland) | Katie Kleine (Fredonia) | Chris Case (Fredonia) | Maria DiFato (Cortland) | |
| 2013 | Maria Di Fato, Cortland | Erica Geremia, Cortland | Carly Ritchlin, Geneseo | Jessica Lavelle, Cortland | |
| 2014 | Erica Geremia (Cortland) | Kelly Wall (Brockport) | Kathy Taylor (Cortland) | Emma Hayes-Hurley (Cortland) | |
| 2015 | Emma Hayes-Hurley (Cortland) | *Colleen Hathaway (Brockport) | Taylor Casey (Oneonta) | Kelly Lickert-Orr (Cortland) | Emma Hayes-Hurley (Cortland) |
| 2016 | Tara Monaghan (Cortland) | Courtney Szczesniak (Brockport) | Teresa Shattuck (Oswego) | Stephen Wagner (Brockport) | Jaclyn Beshlian (Cortland) |
| 2017 | Kelly Wall (Brockport) | Cassandra Minerd (Brockport) | Lexie Meager (Cortland) | Stephen Wagner (Brockport) | Jaclyn Beshlian (Cortland) |
| 2018 | Lexie Meager (Cortland) | Hailey Dobbins (Cortland) | Hannah Marafioti (Geneseo) | Carly Ritchlin (Geneseo) | Hailey Dobbins (Cortland) |
| 2019 | Hannah Marafioti (Geneseo) | Danielle Walker (Oswego) | Allison Jennings (Brockport) | Stephen Wagner (Brockport) | Heather Conklin (Brockport) |
| 2020 | No awards due to COVID-19 | ||||
| Coaching Staff of the Year | |||||
| 2021 | Heather Conklin (Brockport) | Caitlyn Merkel (Geneseo) | Logan Hibbard (Brockport) | Cortland | Hannah Lorenzen (Cortland) |
| 2022 | Hannah Marafioti (Geneseo) | Meg Seeley (Geneseo) | Madelynn Brown (Geneseo) | Cortland | Hannah Lorenzen (Cortland) |
| 2023 | Sela Wiley (Oswego) | Tricia Curran (Geneseo) | Mackenzie Beck (Cortland) | Geneseo | Tricia Curran, Geneseo |
*First time the award was given