| Year | Offensive Player of the Year | Defensive Player of the Year | Rookie of the Year | Tournament MVP | Coaching Staff of the Year |
| 2022 | Natasia Plunkett, New Paltz |
Hailey Roethel, Geneseo Erica Scheblein, Oswego |
Hailey Roethel, Geneseo | Hanna Corrigan, Cortland | Geneseo |
| 2021 | Keirra Ettere, Cortland | Jessica Ascencao, New Paltz | Keirra Ettere, Cortland | Hannah Ackerman, New Paltz | New Paltz |
| 2020 | No season due to COVID-19 | ||||
| Coach of the Year | |||||
| 2019 | Haley Clark, Geneseo | Julia Kim, Geneseo | Maggie Phipps, Geneseo | Erin Nolan, Geneseo | Margaret McConnell, Geneseo |
| 2018 | Jess Gibaldi, Cortland | Julia Kim, Geneseo | Jessica Ascencao, New Paltz | Ryan Dowling, New Paltz | Shanna Szablinski, New Paltz |
| 2017 | Jessica Welsh, Cortland | Meg Redmond, Cortland | Cali Cortese, Oneonta | Jessica Welsh, Cortland | Tiffany Hubbard, Cortland |
| 2016 | Gabby Stein, Cortland | Morgan Maley, Geneseo | Sophia Urrutia, New Paltz | Giovanna Fasanello, Geneseo | Jessica Seren, Geneseo |
| 2015 | Dani Ackerman, New Paltz | Jessica Caruana, New Paltz | Kailynne Reinoehl, Cortland | Dani Ackerman, New Paltz | Shanna Vitale, new Paltz |
| Year | Player of the Year | Rookie of the Year | Tournament MVP | Coach of the Year |
| 2014 | Andrea Day, Oneonta | Sarita Charap, Oswego | Alayna Wageman, New Paltz | Cynthia Wetmore, Cortland |
| 2013 | Erin Smith, Cortland | Gabrielle Stein, Cortland | Kayla McKeveny, New Paltz | Shanna Vitale, New Paltz |
| 2012 | Antonija Pjetri, New Paltz | Dayna Mercer, Geneseo | Antonija Pjetri, New Paltz | Shanna Vitale, New Paltz |
| 2011 | Bridget McGovern, Geneseo | Andrea Day, Oneonta | Erin Smith, Cortland | Shanna Vitale, New Paltz |
| 2010 | Michelle Milkovich, Geneseo | Erin Smith, Cortland | * Michelle Milkovich, Geneseo | Jessica Seren, Geneseo |
| 2009 | Ainsley Stoll, Oneonta | Danielle Groneman, Cortland | N/A | Jessica Seren, Geneseo |
| 2008 | Amanda Pickard, Brockport Kayla Chambers, Cortland |
Kelly Collins, Oswego | N/A | Cynthia Wetmore, Cortland |
| 2007 | Amanda Pickard, Brockport | Michelle Milkovich, Geneseo | N/A | Cynthia Wetmore, Cortland |
| 2006 | Kelli Johnson, Cortland^ | Kathryn Kubaryk, Oneonta Christine McCabe, Cortland |
N/A | Cynthia Wetmore, Cortland |
| 2005 | Kelli Johnson, Cortland^ | Sarah Doster, Geneseo | N/A | Shannon Manzo, Geneseo |
| 2004 | Meg Donnelly, Oneonta | Kaitlin Ruffiero, New Paltz | N/A | Michelle Dombrowski, Oneonta |
| 2003 | Ashley Ostrander, Cortland | Kelli Johnson, Cortland^ | N/A | Cynthia Wetmore, Cortland |
| 2002 | Julie Gentner, Cortland | Jessica Seren, Cortland | N/A | Michelle Dombrowski, Oneonta |
| 2001 | Victoria Brown, Cortland | N/A | Cynthia Wetmore, Cortland | |
| 2000 | Victoria Brown, Cortland | N/A | *Cynthia Wetmore, Cortland |
*First Year awarded
^ SUNYAC Award streak
Kelli Johnson (Cortland), Rookie of the Year 2003 and Player of the Year 2005 and 2006