| Year | Outstanding Female Swimmer | Outstanding Female Diver | Outstanding Male Swimmer | Outstanding Male Diver |
| 2022-23 | Kim MacDonald, Geneseo | Ashley Zachgo, Cortland | Jake Nielsen, Geneseo | Trent Makowiec, Geneseo |
| 2021-22 | Kimberly Macdonald, Geneseo | Taylor Williams, Cortland | Jack Cimorelli, Geneseo | Trent Makowiec, Geneseo |
| 2019-20 | Deidra Osula, Geneseo | Samantha Reichman, Geneseo | Hunter Bernhardt, Cortland | Corey Wirth, Geneseo |
| 2018-19 | Deidra Osula, Geneseo | Samantha Reichman, Geneseo | Clark Davis, Geneseo | Christain Krasnek, Fredonia |
| 2017-18 | Nancy Nasky, Geneseo | Samantha Reichman, Geneseo | Connor Mergler, Buffalo State | Samuel Randall, Geneseo |
| 2016-17 | Nancy Nasky, Geneseo | Meghan Bartlett, Fredonia | Connor Mergler, Buffalo State | Arron Carlson, Fredonia |
| 2015-16 | Hailey Modelewski, Geneseo | Miranda Furgus, Cortland | Connor Mergler, Buffalo State | Arron Carlson, Fredonia |
| 2014-15 | Abigail Max, Geneseo | Meghan Bartlett, Fredonia | John Nasky, Geneseo | Samuel Randall, Geneseo |
| 2013-14 | Abagail Max, Geneseo | Ashley Keller, Fredonia | John Nasky, Geneseo | Jeff Matter, Fredonia |
| 2012-13 | Abigail Max, Geneseo | Ashley Keller, Fredonia | Alex Miller, Oneonta | Ryan Fuller, Fredonia |
| 2011-12 | Yuka Suzuka, New Paltz | Sarah Ficarro, Fredonia | Xander Taylor, Potsdam | Ryan Fuller, Fredonia |
| 2010-11 | Michelle Rodriguez, Geneseo | Sarah Ficarro, Fredonia | Austin Brennan, Geneseo | Wills DeMoulin, Geneseo |
| 2009-10 | Michelle Rodriguez, Geneseo | Sarah Ficarro, Fredonia | Dan Evans, Cortland | Christian Torres, Fredonia Eric Messina, Oswego |
| 2008-09 | Michelle Rodriguez, Geneseo | Kelly Sponholz, Fredonia | Dan Evans, Cortland | Nathan LaRowe, Potsdam |
| 2007-08 | Michelle Coombs, New Paltz | Kelly Sponholz, Fredonia | Greg Doyle, Oswego | Kevin Morgan, Oswego |
| 2006-07 | Michelle Coombs, New Paltz | Kelly Sponholz, Fredonia | Greg Doyle, Oswego | Kevin Morgan, Oswego |
| 2005-06 | Joanna Masterson, New Paltz | Kelly Sponholz, Fredonia | Greg Doyle, Oswego | Kevin Morgan, Oswego |
| 2004-05 | Joanna Masterson, New Paltz | Nicole Rutkowski, Buffalo State | Dan Allen, Geneseo | Kevin Morgan, Oswego |
| 2003-04 | Anne Sarkissian, Oswego | Lisa Cole, Brockport | Andrew Chevalier, Cortland | Scott Horsington, Fredonia |
| 2002-03 | Kellie Winters, Oswego | Amy Sislo, Cortland | Josh Lerch, Oswego | TJ Hirsch, Geneseo |
| 2001-02 | Anne Sarkissian, Oswego | Amy Sislo, Cortland | John Amoia, New Paltz | Josh Grutzik, Oswego |
| 2000-01 | Danielle Schoen, Geneseo | Mandy Birchenough, Oswego | Ryan Warren, Cortland | Chris Miller, Buffalo State |
| 1999-00 | Michelle Standora, Geneseo | Kari Herlihy, Potsdam | Andy Grimaldi, Potsdam | Mike Pacifico, Geneseo |
| 1998-99 | Claudine Gruver, New Paltz | Kari Herlihy, Potsdam | Josh Muldner, Geneseo | Devon Hainey, Oswego |
| 1997-98 | Beth Whitehead, Cortland | Kari Herlihy, Potsdam | Kevin Crossman, Cortland | Ricker Fredericks, Cortland |
| 1996-97 | Jessica Covert, Cortland | Jill Reimer, Oswego | Matt VanDerMeid, Geneseo | Mike Pacifico, Geneseo |
| 1995-96 | Beth Schroeder, Binghamton | Jill Reimer, Oswego | Josh Muldner, Geneseo | Jeff Cohen, Binghamton |
|
Outstanding Female of Meet |
No Outstanding Male of the Meet prior to 1995-96. Only award given was the James Fulton Award. | |||
| 1994-95 | Sharon Clark, Geneseo | |||
| 1993-94 | Karen Adams, New Paltz | |||
| 1992-93 | Karann Andrusky, Oswego | |||
| 1991-92 | Lisa Heidt, Geneseo | |||
| 1990-91 | Jennifer Zaboris, Binghamton | |||
| 1989-90 | Kim Iak, Cortland | |||
| 1988-89 | Kim Kendrick, Cortland | |||
| 1987-88 | Jackie Miller, Potsdam | |||
| 1986-87 | Nancy Adams, Cortland | |||
| 1985-86 | Joanne Adams, Cortland | |||
| 1984-85 | Anne Donato, Potsdam | |||