| Year | Female Swimmer of the Year |
Female Diver of the Year |
Male Swimmer of the Year |
Male Diver of the Year |
Female Rookie of the Year | Male Rookie of the Year |
| 2022-23 | Kim MacDonald, Geneseo | Ashley Zachgo, Cortland | Jake Nielsen, Geneseo | Trent Makowiec, Geneseo | Hannah Brockman, Geneseo | Jake Nielsen, Geneseo |
| 2021-22 | Kim MacDonald, Geneseo | Taylor Williams, Cortland | Ben Ludlow, Geneseo | Trent Makowiec, Geneseo | Elizabeth Sagan, Brockport | Mark Crocker, Geneseo |
| 2020-21 | No awards - canceled due to Covid-19 | |||||
| 2019-20 | No awards - NCAA championships canceled due to COVID-19 | |||||
| 2018-19 | Deidra Osula, Geneseo | Samantha Reichman, Geneseo | Clark Davis, Geneseo | Corey Wirith, Geneseo | Julia Torell, Cortland | Sean McClellan, Geneseo |
| 2017-18 | Nancy Nasky, Geneseo | Meghann Kilgallon, Brockport | Cooper Knapp, New Paltz | Samuel Randall, Geneseo | Lauren Siegel, Geneseo | Brandon Amthor, Brockport |
| 2016-17 | Nancy Nasky, Geneseo | Meghan Bartlett, Fredonia | Connor Mergler, Buffalo | Arron Carlson, Fredonia | Emily Ross, Oswego | Cooper Knapp, New Paltz |
| 2015-16 | Nancy Nasky, Geneseo | Meghan Bartlett, Fredonia | Connor Mergler, Buffalo | Samuel Randall, Geneseo | ||
| 2014-15 | Abigail Max, Geneseo | Meghan Bartlett, Fredonia | John Nasky, Geneseo | Samuel Randall, Geneseo | ||
Started in 2014-15