| Year | Offensive Player of the Year | Defensive Player of the Year | Rookie of the Year | Tournament MVP | Coaching Staff of the Year |
|
2022 |
Jaden Galuluzzo, Cortland | Bryn Thompson, Cortland | Brooke Kelleher, New Paltz | Lindsay Wright, Geneseo | New Paltz |
|
2021 |
Kirsten Villemaire, Plattsburgh | Julia Dell Aquila, Geneseo | Liv Raucci, Geneseo | Hannah Sullivan, Geneseo | Geneseo |
|
2020 |
Cancelled due to COVID-19 | Coach of the Year | |||
|
2019 |
Lexi Dean, Potsdam | Taylor Clar, Geneseo | Kiley Longin, Brockport | Jaden Galluzzo, Cortland | Heidi Axtell, Cortland |
|
2018 |
Brooke Falsion, |
Emily Janiszewski, Geneseo |
Allison Seidman, Plattsburgh |
Jennifer Moran, Geneseo |
Nate Wiley, Geneseo |
|
2017 |
Madeline Saccocio, Plattsburgh |
Leah Greene, Geneseo | Ellie Gregory, Geneseo | Audrey Reid, Geneseo | Mark Misiak, Potsdam |
| 2016 | Melissa Smith, Buffalo St. | Kristin Seiferth, Buffalo St. | Taylor Carillo, Buffalo St. | Melissa Smith, Buffalo St. | Nicholas DeMarsh, Buffalo St. |
| 2015 | Melissa Smith, Buffalo St. | Gabrianna Boldinski, Buffalo St. | Chloe Lonergan | Kayla Ceschini, Oneonta | Nicholas DeMarsh, Buffalo St. |
| Year | Player of the Year | Rookie of the Year | Tournament MVP | Coach of the Year |
| 2014 | Meghan Johnston, Geneseo | Leah Greene, Geneseo | Leah Greene, Geneseo | Nate Wiley, Geneseo |
| 2013 | Karly DeSimone, Oneonta | Chelsea Stahl, Brockport | Karly DeSimone, Oneonta | Brian McGrane, Oswego |
| 2012 | Kayla Brantmeyer, Oneonta | Krystal Scott, Oneonta | Kelly Knight, Cortland | Joan Schockow, Brockport |
| 2011 | Pam Monnier, Cortland | Amanda Margolis, Cortland | Stephanie Vega, New Paltz | Colleen Bruley, New Paltz |
| 2010 | Barbara Kiliszek, Buffalo State | Karly DeSimone, Oneonta | Erin Boyle, Oneonta | Nick DeMarsh, Buffalo State |
| 2009 | Lindsey Feuz, Geneseo | Kayla Brantmeyer, Oneonta | Melissa Beale, Geneseo | Chris Case, Fredonia |
| 2008 | Christine Marra, Oneonta | Reilly Condidorio, Fredonia | Lindsey Brechbiel, Oneonta | Joan Schockow, Brockport |
| 2007 | Mary Velan, Oneonta | Helen Giroux, Plattsburgh | Mary Velan, Oneonta | Heidi Woodcock, Cortland |
| 2006 | Mary Velan, Oneonta | Nicole Gibaud, Brockport | Molly Berkstresser, Brockport | Joan Schockow, Brockport |
| 2005 | Patricia Jaegar, Oneonta | Katie Trivisonna, Cortland | Patricia Jaegar, Oneonta^ | Tracey Ranieri, Oneonta |
| 2004 | Jackie Fertitta, Geneseo | Mary Velan, Oneonta | Patricia Jaegar, Oneonta^ | Colleen Bruley, New Paltz |
| 2003 | Logan Hadzicki, Geneseo | Andrea Marino, Cortland | Patricia Jaegar, Oneonta^ | Chris Case, Fredonia |
| 2002 | Logan Hadzicki, Geneseo | Jackie Fertitta, Geneseo Maureen Kasperek, Oswego Gena Rosenbaum, Plattsburgh |
Kelly Stevens, Oneonta | Aimee Canale, Geneseo |
| 2001 | Amy Ducharme, Oneonta | Jodi Ziemba, Potsdam | *Liz Grosser, Oneonta | Tracey Ranieri, Oneonta |
| 2000 | Elizabeth McGrail, Oneonta^ | Logan Hadzicki, Geneseo Cristina Gaspar, Oneonta |
Tracey Ranieri, Oneonta | |
| 1999 | Elizabeth McGrail, Oneonta^ | Cassie Knudsen, Cortland | Tracey Ranieri, Oneonta | |
| 1998 | Elizabeth McGrail, Oneonta^ Karen Perrotta, Plattsburgh |
*Zoey D'Arienzo, Plattsburgh | Karen Wiley, Plattsburgh | |
| 1997 | Missy Verdoliva, Oswego | Tracey Ranieri, Oneonta | ||
| 1996 | Aimee Canale, Geneseo | Sue Viscomi, Oswego | ||
| 1995 | Janet Urban, Cortland | Dave Wilson, Binghamton | ||
| 1994 | West: Tracy Florence, Geneseo East: Deb Mard, Binghamton |
Dave Wilson, Binghamton Lisa Siegel, Fredonia |
||
| 1993 | West: Carin Halleran, Geneseo East: Donna Priano, Cortland |
Joan Schockow, Brockport | ||
| 1992 | West: Barb Verdoliva, Oswego East: Janine Caruso, |
Chris Malone, Cortland | ||
| 1991 | West: Betsy Balling, Geneseo East: Leslie Benintend, Cortland |
Sue Viscomi, Oswego | ||
| 1990 | West: Shannon McHale, Brockport East: Janine Engelhard, Cortland |
Chris Malone, Cortland | ||
| 1989 | West: Chris Camera, Geneseo East: Melissa Cohen, Binghamton |
Joan Schockow, Brockport | ||
| 1988 | West: Donna Clark, Oswego East: Joan Eason, Cortland |
Ronald Hess, New Paltz | ||
| 1987 | West: Julie Rivons, Geneseo East: Leslie Moore, Cortland |
Chris Malone, Cortland | ||
| 1986 | West: Colleen Burruto, Geneseo East: T'She Looney, Cortland |
Ron Case, Univ. of Buffalo | ||
| 1985 | West: Colleen Burruto, Geneseo East: Lori Beesmer, Cortland |
*Chris Malone, Cortland Fred Bright, Geneseo |
*First Year awarded
^ SUNYAC Award streak
Elizabeth McGrail (Oneonta), Player of the Year 1998, 1999 and 2000
Patricia Jaegar (Oneonta), Tournament MVP 2003, 2004, and 2005