| Year | Player of the Year | Defensive Player of the Year | Rookie of the Year | Tournament MVP | Coach of the Year |
| 2022 |
Zoe Staats, Cortland |
Emily Haber, Geneseo |
Emma Reilly, Cortland | Allie Sturgess, Cortland | Erin Glickert, Cortland |
| 2021 |
Hannah Southcott, Cortland |
Carly Haegele, Cortland |
Megan Loomis, Brockport | Nicole Van Pelt, Cortland | Erin Glickert, Cortland |
| 2020 |
Cancelled due to COVID-19 |
||||
| 2019 |
Grace Cergol, Geneseo |
Sam Mendelsohn, Geneseo |
Carly Haegele, Cortland | Meaghan Mastro, Brockport | Steve Pike, Brockport |
| 2018 |
Grace Cergol, |
Natalie Magallon, |
Maddie McLaughlin, Geneseo |
Meredith Dignan, New Paltz |
Matt Giufre, New Paltz |
| 2017 | Grace Cergol, Geneseo |
Courtney Poirier, Fredonia Sam Mendelsohn,Geneseo Veronica Matedero, New Paltz |
Meghan Mastro, Brockport | DeAnna Ortiz-Whittemore, Brockport | Geoff Braun, Fredonia |
| 2016 | Morgan Roessler, New Paltz | Veronica Matedero, New Paltz | Kelly Waters, Brockport | Sam Holdredge, Brockport | Steve Pike, Borckport |
| Year | Player of the Year | Rookie of the Year | Tournament MVP | Coach of the Year | ||
| 2015 | Kayla Barber/Becca Borquist, Brockport/ New Paltz | Ariel Murawski | Kayla Barber, Brockport | Steve Pike, Borckport | ||
| 2014 | Becca Borquist, New Paltz | Maddie Zwickl, New Paltz | Becca Borquist, New Paltz | Matt Giufre, New Paltz | ||
| 2013 | Rosi Cummings, Plattsburgh | Morgan Roessler, New Paltz | Samantha Parente, Buffalo State | Matt Giufre, New Paltz | ||
| East Player | East Rookie | West Player | West Rookie | |||
| 2012 | Kristen Guercio, Cortland | Becca Borquist, New Paltz | Kelsey Bashore, Buffalo State | Hannah Renaldo, Buffalo State | Natalie Zacpal, Cortland | Pam Hoerup, Cortland |
| 2011 | Ashley Coyle, Cortland | Katy Herbst, New Paltz | Brittany Lis, Fredonia | Jamie Snyder, Brockport | Ashley Coyle, Cortland | Pam Hoerup, Cortland |
| 2010 | Ashley Coyle, Cortland | Carrie Hack, New Paltz | Krista Frieling, Geneseo | Noelle Morrison, Geneseo | Kristen Guercio, Cortland | Pam Hoerup, Cortland |
| 2009 | Brittany Coyle, New Paltz | Katie Wick, Cortland | Alyssa Fitchette, Brockport | Laura Galvin, Geneseo | Brittany Coyle, New Paltz | Matt Giufre, New Paltz |
| 2008 | Michelle Gaufman, Cortland | Courtney Falconer, Potsdam | Kaitlin Erdmann, Fredonia | Chelsea Senn, Fredonia | Leanne Maloney, Fredonia | Geoff Braun, Fredonia |
| 2007 | Katie Becofsky, New Paltz^ | Kim Plummer, Potsdam | Kaylen Fessette, Brockport^ | Kaitlin Erdmann, Fredonia | Brittany Horton, Cortland | Geoff Braun, Fredonia |
| 2006 | Katie Becofsky, New Paltz^ | Brittany Coyle, New Paltz | Kaylen Fessette, Brockport^ | Laura Lobaugh, Buffalo State | Brittany Horton, Cortland | Matt Giufre, New Paltz |
| 2005 | Christina Mazurowski, New Paltz | Tiffany Chatman, Cortland | Shannon Hennigan, Oswego | Bethany Kibbe, Fredonia Ashley Saltzman, Geneseo |
Danielle Turner, Cortland | Steve Pike, Potsdam |
| 2004 | Katie Brody, Cortland | Katie Becofsky, New Paltz^ | Kate Barth, Geneseo | Kaylen Fessette, Brockport^ Kate Barth, Geneseo |
Jamie McMullen, Cortland | Matt Giufre, New Paltz |
| 2003 | Andrea Smith, Cortland | Katie Brody, Cortland | Heather Martin, Fredonia | Katie Feldman, Brockport | Geoff Braun, Fredonia | |
| 2002 | Jackie Goldstein, New Paltz Lacey Musso, Oneonta |
Jen Maziarz, Plattsburgh | Monica Polka, Buffalo State | Erin Hanlon, Oswego | Colleen Cashman, Oneonta | |
| 2001 | Allison Clark, Cortland | Monica Polka, Buffalo State | David McClary, Buffalo State | |||
| 2000 | Colleen Cashman, Oneonta | |||||
| 1999 | Joan Sitterly, Cortland | |||||
| 1998 | Joan Sitterly, Cortland Antonio Bonilla, New Paltz |
|||||
| 1997 | Joan Sitterly, Cortland | |||||
| 1996 | Joan Sitterly, Cortland | |||||
| 1995 | Sheryl Sousa, Binghamton | |||||
| 1994 | Dani Drews, Oswego | |||||
| 1993 | Joan Sitterly, Cortland | |||||
| 1992 | Steve Garner, Oneonta | |||||
| 1991 | Frank Short, Brockport | |||||
| 1990 | Joan Sitterly, Cortland Dani Martin, Oswego |
|||||
| 1989 | Frank Short, Brockport | |||||
| 1988 | Joan Sitterly, Cortland | |||||
| 1987 | Jean Mathias, Binghamton | |||||
^ SUNYAC Award streak
East Player: Katie Becofsky (New Paltz), Rookie of the Year 2004 and Player of the Year 2006 and 2007
West Player: Kaylen Fessette (Brockport), Rookie of the Year 2004 and Player of the Year 2006 and 2007