July 12, 2017
2015-2016
| ATHLETE | SPORT | SCHOOL |
| Connor Griffin | Baseball | Cortland |
| Faith Welch | Basketball | Brockport |
| Emily Lindsay | Equestrian | Geneseo |
| Elena Hingston | Field Hockey | Geneseo |
| Madeline Scozzie | Gymnastics | Cortland |
| Bridget Balisy | Ice Hockey | Plattsburgh |
| Spencer Finney | Ice Hockey | Plattsburgh |
| Esther Gabriel | Lacrosse | Oswego |
| Dylan Williams | Soccer | Oneonta |
| Chloe Longergan | Soccer | Oswego |
| Jordan Ott | Softball | Potsdam |
| Jenna Gibbons | Swimming | Geneseo |
| Jeff Doser | Swimming and Diving | Geneseo |
| Lauren Salzano | Tennis | Geneseo |
| Sasa Vann | Track and Field, Outdoor | Buffalo |
| Ashton Hughes | Track and Field, X-Country | Geneseo |
| Noelle Poloncarz | Volleyball | Brockport |
| Christopher Husmann | Volleyball | New Paltz |