2012-13
| ATHLETE | SPORT | SCHOOL |
| Tim Chambers | Men's Cross Country | Geneseo |
| Mary Aldridge | Women's Cross Country | Geneseo |
| Kim Lepore | Field Hockey | New Paltz |
| Mike Payne | Men's Soccer | Plattsburgh |
| Melissa Mahoney | Women's Soccer | Buffalo State |
| Paige Munroe | Women's Tennis | New Paltz |
| Hannah Manning | Women's Volleyball | Fredonia |
| Zachary Best | Football | Buffalo State |
| Becky Hebert | Women's Basketball | Fredonia |
| Gordon Lyons | Men's Basketball | Geneseo |
| Elise Konikoff | Women's Gymnastics | Cortland |
| Adam Shearer | Men's Indoor Track and Field | Plattsburgh |
| Alyssa Smith | Women's Indoor Track and Field | Geneseo |
| Jack Caradonna | Men's Ice Hockey | Geneseo |
| Katelyn Komsa | Women's Ice Hockey | Potsdam |
| Eliah Golding | Wrestling | Brockport |
| N/A | Men's Swimming and Diving | N/A |
| Jessica Evans | Women's Swimming and Diving | Cortland |
| Brian Hamilton | Baseball | Oswego |
| Carlene Benson | Equestrian | Potsdam |
| John Felix | Men's Lacrosse | Geneseo |
| Bailey Weigel | Women's Lacrosse | Potsdam |
| Ben Depo | Men's Outdoor Track and Field | Plattsburgh |
| Rachel Malone | Women's Outdoor Track and Field | Brockport |
| Shayna Burgess | Softball | New Paltz |