Semifinals
Geneseo beat Oneonta 14-2
Cortland beat Potsdam, 19-5
Final
Cortland beat Geneseo 11-8
2020 - No tournament due to COVID-19
2016
| 2015 Semis: Finals: |
#1 Cortland 21, #4 Oneonta 5 #2 Plattsburgh 15, #3 Potsdam 7 #1 Cortland 14, #2 Plattsburgh 12 |
| 2014 Semis: Finals: |
#1 Cortland 15, #4 Oneonta 3 #2 Potsdam 6, #3 Plattsburgh 11 #1 Cortland 11, #3 Plattsburgh 10 |
| 2013 Semis: Finals: |
#1 Cortland 16, #4 Potsdam 5 #2 Plattsburgh 15, #3Brockport 7 #1 Cortland 9, #2 Plattsburgh 2 |
| 2012 Semis: Finals: |
#1 Cortland 20, #4 Oneonta 3 #2 Geneseo 7, #3 Plattsburgh 5 #1 Cortland 9, #2 Geneseo 2 |
| 2011 Semis: Finals: |
#1 Cortland 13, #4 Brockport 5 #2 Potsdam 18, #3 Geneseo 17 #1 Cortland 16, #2 Potsdam 3 |
| 2010 Semis: Finals |
#1 Cortland 17, #4 Potsdam 2 #2 Geneseo 19, #3 Oneonta 11 #1 Cortland 17, #2 Geneseo 5 |
| 2009 Semis: Finals: |
#1 Geneseo 21, #4 Plattsburgh 11 #2 Cortland 25, #3 Oswego 3 #1 Geneseo 13, #2 Cortland 14 |
| 2008 Semis: Finals: |
#1 Cortland 18, #4 Oneonta 6 #2 Geneseo 16, #3 Cortland 8 #1 Cortland 19, #2 Geneseo 6 |
| 2007 Semis: Finals: |
#1 Cortland 13 , #4 Oneonta 3 #2 Geneseo 14, #3 Potsdam 8 #1 Cortland 15, #2 Geneseo 16 |
| 2006 Semis: Finals: |
#1 Geneseo 12, #4 Oswego 4 #2 Cortland 8, #3 Oneonta 5 #1 Geneseo 7, #2 Cortland 13 |
| 2005 Semis: Finals: |
#1 Cortland 14, #4 Potsdam 9 #2 Geneseo 14, #3 Oneonta 8 #1 Cortland 20, #2 Geneseo 8 |
| 2004 Semis: Finals: |
#1 Cortland 13, #4 Potsdam 6 #2 Geneseo 13, #3 Oneonta 7 #1 Cortland 6, #2 Geneseo 8 |
| 2003 Semis: Finals: |
#1 Cortland 15, #4 Potsdam 9 #2 Geneseo 15, #3 Oneonta 8 #1 Cortland 11, #2 Geneseo 4 |
| 2002 Semis: Finals: |
#1 Cortland 13, #4 Geneseo 0 #2 Oneonta 22, #3 Oswego 12 #1 Cortland 13, #2 Geneseo 8 |
Site = Higher Seed