| Year | Most Outstanding Performance | Most Valuable Performer | Coaching Staff of the Year | Track Athlete of the Year | Field Athlete of the Year | Rookie of the Year |
| 2022 | Art Jordan, Brockport | Art Jordan, Brockport Brett Morse, Cortland |
Geneseo | Nick Andrews, Geneseo | Art Jordan, Brockport | Ryan Cory, Cortland |
| 2021 | Devin Kipp, Brockport | Matthew Sayre, Geneseo | Geneseo | Matthew Sayre, Geneseo | Dane Sorensen, Cortland | Ryan Mitchell, Geneseo |
| Outstanding Track Athlete of the Meet | Outstanding Field Athlete of the Meet | Coach of the Year (M) | Track Athlete of the Year | Field Athlete of the Year | Rookie of the Year | |
|
2020 |
No awards - season canceled due to COVID-19 | |||||
|
2019 |
Tyler O'Bryant, Oneonta | Tony DeYoung, Brockport | Chris Popovici, Geneseo | Tyler O'Bryant, Oneonta | Norberto Cervantes, Oneonta | Adam Parker, Potsdam |
| 2018 |
Robert Liebel, Buffalo State |
Anthony DeYoung, Brockport |
Chris Popovici, Geneseo |
Isaac Garcia-Cassani, Geneseo |
Anthony DeYoung, Brockport | Lukas D'Alfonso, Geneseo |
| 2017 | Robert Liebel, Bufalo State |
Jon Rogers, Brockport |
Steve Patrick, Cortland | Isaac Garcia-Cassani, Geneseo | Jack Flood, Cortland | Cody Sikora, Buffalo State |
| 2016 | Joe Carr, Oneonta | Mitchel Couch, Cortland |
Steve Patrick, Cortland |
|||
| 2015 | Samuel Taft, Brockport | Antoine Keels, Brockport |
Ed Jaskulski, Brockport |
|||
| 2014 | Joe Carr, Oneonta | Pat Weinert, Oneonta |
Angelo Posillico, Oneonta |
|||
| 2013 | Sean Bernstein, Oneonta | Ben Depo, Plattsburgh |
Steve Patrick, Cortland |
|||
| 2012 | Sean Bernstein, Oneonta | Dustin Colgan, Brockport |
Steve Patrick, Cortland |
|||
| 2011 | Xavier Mateen, Buffalo State | Ray Lund, Brockport |
Tom Wilson, Fredonia |
|||
| 2010 | Justin Allen, Buffalo State | Ray Lund, Brockport |
Dave Prevosti, Geneseo |
|||
| 2009 | Willie Hordge, Buffalo State | Ryan Pericozzi, Cortland |
Dave Prevosti, Geneseo |
|||
| 2008 | Amaan Siddeeq, Cortland | Josh Dupuis, Brockport |
Steve Patrick, Cortland |
|||
| 2007 | Willie Hordge, Buffalo State | Josh Dupuis, Brockport |
Matt Moran, Cortland |
|||
| 2006 | Ross Hunkovic, Geneseo | Matt Kuenzel, Geneseo |
Shawn Wilbourn, Cortland |
|||
| 2005 |
Shawn Wilbourn, Cortland |
|||||
| 2004 |
John Crawford, Cortland |
|||||
| 2003 |
Mike Woods, Geneseo |
|||||
| 2002 |
Larry Czarnecki, Cortland |
|||||
| 2001 |
Larry Czarnecki, Cortland |
|||||
| 2000 |
Ed O'Gorman, Fredonia |
|||||
| 1999 |
Ed O'Gorman, Fredonia |
|||||
| 1998 |
Jim Ulrich, Fredonia |
|||||
| 1997 |
Brian Lange, Cortland |
|||||
| 1996 |
Jim Ulrich, Fredonia |
|||||
| 1995 |
Jim Ulrich, Fredonia |
|||||
| 1994 |
Jim Ulrich, Fredonia |
|||||
| 1993 |
Jim Ulrich, Fredonia |
|||||
| 1992 |
Jim Ulrich, Fredonia |
|||||
| 1991 |
Gary Truce, Binghamton Jim Ulrich, Fredonia |
|||||
| 1990 |
Gary Truce, Binghamton |
|||||
| 1989 |
Jim Ulrich (Fredonia) |
|||||
| 1988 |
Jim Ulrich, Fredonia |
|||||
| 1987 |
Jim Ulrich, Fredonia |
|||||
| 1986 |
Brett Hull, Cortland |
|||||
| 1985 |
Ed Matejkovic, Brockport |
|||||
| 1984 |
Jim Ulrich, Fredonia |
|||||
| 1983 |
Jim Ulrich, Fredonia |
|||||
| 1982 |
Joe Pierson, Cortland |
|||||
| 1981 |
Jim Ulrich, Fredonia Mike Collopy, Buffalo State |