| Year | Julie Lenhart Player of the Year | Pitcher of the Year | Rookie of the Year | Tournament MVP | Coaching Staff of the Year |
| 2023 |
Jackie Rometo, New Paltz |
Lindsay Roman, New Paltz | Brooke Fraas, Geneseo | Rebecca Schwartz, Geneseo | New Paltz |
| 2022 |
Katie Quagliana, New Paltz |
Lauren Kersch, Geneseo | Halle Wright, Cortland Julia Serena, Oneonta |
Kaitlyn Schmitz, Geneseo | Geneseo |
| 2021 |
Orianna Castello, Buffalo State Kelly O'Gorman, Cortland |
Nicol Schwartz, Geneseo | Tori Reich, Cortland | Anna Johnston, Geneseo | Buffalo State |
| 2020 |
No awards due to COVID-19 |
||||
| Player of the Year | Coach of the Year | ||||
| 2019 |
Danni Napoli, Geneseo |
Sam Van Dorn, Cortland | Katie Quagliana, New Paltz | Cady Walts, Cortland | Julie Lenhart, Cortland |
| 2018 | Rebecca Vilchez, Oswego | Rebecca Vilchez, Oswego | Caroline Koch, Oneonta | Ashlyn Kersch, Geneseo | Dave Sylvester, Geneseo |
| 2017 | Niki Barbato, Cortland | Jamie Lachall, Cortland | Katie Yudin, Fredonia/Haleigh Agans, Plattsburgh | Sam Van Dorn, Cortland | Abby Martin, Oswego |
| 2016 | Jamie Bucci, Cortland | Alexandrea Flint, Cortland | Jennifer Groat, Plattsburgh | Alexandrea Flint, Cortland | Stephanie Conroy, Plattsburgh |
| 2015 | Brianna Rivera, Oneonta | Jamie Lachall, Cortland Corrin Spallone, Geneseo |
Ashley Lefebvre, Oneonta | Diane Cook, Cortland | Julie Lenhart, Cortland |
| 2014 | Meaghan Kohler, Cortland | Sabrina DeAngelis, Oneonta | Sabrina DeAngelis, Oneonta | Sabrina DeAngelis, Oneonta | Sara Headley, Oneonta |
| 2013 | Lucia “Cheech” Meola, Cortland | Ashley Marshall, Plattsburgh | Diane Cork, Cortland | Amber Corrigan, Cortland | Casey Price, Oswego |
| 2012 | Meaghan Kohler, Cortland | Ashley Marshall, Plattsburgh | Brittany Marshall, Plattsburgh | Ashley Marshall, Plattsburgh | Sandy Hollander and Marie Curran, Buffalo State |
| 2011 | Donnalyn Cross, Cortland^ | Lyndsay Rowell, Cortland | Alyssa Brognano, Fredonia | Lyndsay Rowell, Cortland | Lorrie Corsi, Fredonia |
| 2010 | Donnalyn Cross, Cortland^ | Katie Finch, Cortland | Katie Bartkowiak, Fredonia | Katie Finch, Cortland | Julie Lenhart, Cortland |
| 2009 | Donnalyn Cross, Cortland^ Nicole Subuda, Buffalo State |
Katie Finch, Cortland | Jessica Harmen, Cortland | Nicole Subuda, Buffalo State | Sandy Hollander, Buffalo State John Dumaw, Brockport |
| 2008 | Courtney Turchan, Brockport | Katie Finch, Cortland | Donnalyn Cross, Cortland^ | Katie Finch, Cortland | Sandy Hollander, Buffalo State |
| 2007 | Jamie Neuner, Cortland | Stephanie Zweig, Plattsburgh | Katie Finch, Cortland | Julie Lenhart, Cortland | |
| 2006 | Jamie Neuner, Cortland | Stephanie Zweig, Plattsburgh | Jolene Banach, Buffalo State | Sean Cotter, Plattsburgh | |
| 2005 | Jamie Neuner, Cortland | Stephanie Adamshick, Cortland | Shara Evanter, Cortland | Julie Lenhart, Cortland | |
| 2004 | Lara Stone, Cortland | Stephanie Adamshick, Cortland | Lauren Mruk, Buffalo State | Lorrie Corsi, Fredonia | |
| 2003 | Kim Comtois, Brockport | Sarah Taub, Geneseo | Jennifer Rockwell, Cortland | Tony Ciccarello, Geneseo | |
| 2002 | Sarah Taub, Geneseo | Alyssa Brosius, Buffalo State | Tony Ciccarello, Geneseo | ||
| 2001 | Melanie Yaskulski, Fredonia | Cara LiMongelli, Oneonta | Don Flewelling, Oneonta | ||
| 2000 | Lorrie Corsi, Fredonia | ||||
| 1999 | Don Flewelling, Oneonta | ||||
| 1998 | Joe French, Geneseo | ||||
| 1997 | Julie Lenhart, Cortland | ||||
| 1996 | Holly Brown, Binghamton Sandy Hollander, Buffalo State |
||||
| 1995 | Peter Girolamo, Binghamton | ||||
| 1994 | Peter Girolamo, Binghamton | ||||
| 1993 | Michele Carron, Brockport | ||||
| 1992 | Jan Schefkowitz, Cortland | ||||
| 1991 | Len Maiorani, Brockport | ||||
| 1990 | Sandy Hollander, Buffalo State | ||||
| 1989 | Len Maiorani, Brockport | ||||
| 1988 | Mark Moyer, Binghamton Len Maiorani, Brockport |
||||
| 1987 | Janet Schefkowitz, Cortland | ||||
| 1986 | Len Maiorani, Brockport | ||||
| 1985 | Nan Harvey, Univ. of Buffalo | ||||
| 1984 | Helen Nikiel, Buffalo State |
^ SUNYAC Award streak
Donnalyn Cross (Cortland), Rookie of the Year 2008 and Player of the Year 2009, 2010, and 2011