| EVENT | NAME (School) | YEAR | RECORD |
| 50 Free | Jake Nielsen (Geneseo) | 2024 | :20.18 |
| 100 Free | Connor Mergler (Buffalo State) | 2018 | :44.11 |
| 200 Free | Connor Mergler (Buffalo State) | 2018 | 1:37.87 |
| 500 Free | Louis Petto (New Paltz) | 1994 | 4:30.35 |
| 1000 Free | John Nasky (Geneseo) | 2014 | 9:29.01 |
| 1650 Free | John Nasky (Geneseo) | 2015 | 15:41.88 |
| 100 Back | Cooper Knapp (New Paltz) | 2017 | :49.85 |
| 200 Back | Griffin Merkling (Geneseo) | 2023 | 1:50.07 |
| 100 Breast | Zach Brown (Oswego) | 2024 | :55.21 |
| 200 Breast | Jake Cimorelli (Geneseo) | 2023 | 2:02.22 |
| 100 Fly | Mark Crocker (Geneseo) | 2022 | :48.59 |
| 200 Fly | Cooper Knapp (New Paltz) | 2018 | 1:46.45 |
| 200 IM | Cooper Knapp (New Paltz) | 2018 | 1:48.28 |
| 400 IM | Cooper Knapp (New Paltz) | 2018 | 3:55.47 |
| 1-Meter Diving (6) | Sam Randall (Geneseo) | 2018 | 385 |
| 1-Meter Diving (11) | Sam Randall (Geneseo) | 2018 | 590.4 |
| 3-Meter Diving (6) | Nathan LaRowe (Potsdam) | 2010 | 403.87 |
| 3- Meter Diving (11) | Trent Makowiec (Geneseo) | 2023 | 604.30 |
| 200 Free Relay | Geneseo | 2023 | 1:19.82 |
| Mark Crocker, Jordan Nielsen, Sam Matthews, Jake Nielsen | |||
| 400 Free Relay | Geneseo | 2023 | 3:00.99 |
| Sam Matthews, Jake Nielsen, Jordan Nielsen, Mark Crocker | |||
| 800 Free Relay | Geneseo | 2023 | 6:44.48 |
| Sam Matthews, Griffin Merkling, Christopher Weber, Charlie Wangelin | |||
| 200 Medley Relay | Geneseo | 2024 | 1:28.78 |
| Griffin Merkling, Jake Nielsen, Ben Ludlow and Jordan Nielsen | |||
| 400 Medley Relay | Geneseo | 2023 | 3:19.61 |
| Jack Cimorelli, Jake Nielsen, Mark Crocker, Sam Matthews |
SUNYAC Men's Swimming and Diving began in the 1962-63 season.