| Year | Most Outstanding Performance | Most Valuable Performer | Coaching Staff of the Year | Track Athlete of the Year | Field Athlete of the Year | Rookie of the Year |
| 2022 | Madison Mulder, Geneseo | Sarah Crockett, Brockport | Geneseo | Madison Mulder, Geneseo | Sarah Crockett, Brockport | Kaitlyn Grossman, Geneseo |
| 2021 | Emily Pomainville, Geneseo | Emily Lavarnway, Geneseo | Geneseo | Emily Pomainville, Geneseo | Emily Lavarnway, Geneseo |
Danielle Fisk, Cortland Rachel Hirschkind, Geneseo |
| Year | Outstanding Track Athlete of the Meet | Outstanding Field Athlete of the Meet | Coaching Staff of the Year | Track Athlete of the Year | Field Athlete of the Year | Rookie of the Year |
| 2020 | No season due to COVID-19 | |||||
| 2019 | Erin McDougall, Geneseo | Jessica Craven, Brockport | Geneseo | Elise Ramirez, Geneseo | Victoria Whimple, Plattsburgh | Victoria Whimple, Plattsburgh |
| Coach of the Year | ||||||
| 2018 | Taryn Prutsman, Brockport | Victoire Kothor, Brockport | Chris Popovici, Geneseo | Stephanie Boucher, Plattsburgh | Victoire Kothor, Brockport | Emily Lavarnway, Geneseo |
| 2017 | Stephanie Boucher, Plattsburgh | Alexa Wandy, Geneseo | Chris Popovici, Geneseo | Stephanie Boucher, Plattsburgh | Alexa Wandy, Geneseo | Mariah Mays, Brockport |
| 2016 | Jazlyn Porter, Buffalo State | Jessica Craven, Brockport |
Angelo Posillico, Oneonta |
|||
| 2015 | Rachel Shine, Oneonta | Amanda Gadway, Plattsburgh | Chris Popovici, Geneseo | |||
| 2014 | Anna Dambacher, Fredonia | Taylor Hudson, Cortland | Steve Patrick, Cortland | |||
| 2013 | Jazmin Dunham, Buffalo State | Nicole Jones, Brockport | Steve Patrick, Cortland | |||
| 2012 | Jazmin Dunham, Buffalo State | Sarah Timmons, Oneonta | Steve Patrick, Cortland | |||
| 2011 | Alyssa Smith, Geneseo | Kacy Boburka, Oneonta | Steve Patrick, Cortland | |||
| 2010 | LaToya Edwards, Buffalo State | Sarah Timmons, Oneonta | Dave Prevosti, Geneseo | |||
| 2009 | Melissa Scorse, Brockport | Julia Hopson, Fredonia | Ed Jaskulski, Brockport | |||
| 2008 | Alanna Hollborn, Cortland | Julia Hopson, Fredonia | Dave Prevosti, Geneseo | |||
| 2007 | Kaitlin O'Sullivan, Oneonta | Julia Hopson, Fredonia | Matt Moran, Cortland | |||
| 2006 | Musu Jackson-Buckner, Oneonta | Liz Jacobson, Buffalo State | Mark Krueger, Brockport | |||
| 2005 |
Mark Krueger, Brockport |
|||||
| 2004 |
Mike Woods, Geneseo |
|||||
| 2003 |
Mike Woods, Geneseo |
|||||
| 2002 |
Jennifer Potter, Cortland |
|||||
| 2001 |
Jennifer Potter, Cortland |
|||||
| 2000 |
Jennifer Potter, Cortland |
|||||
| 1999 | Larry Czarnecki, Cortland | |||||
| 1998 |
Brian Lange, Cortland |
|||||
| 1997 |
Penny Hite, Fredonia |
|||||
| 1996 |
John Izzo, Brockport |
|||||
| 1995 |
Jack Daniels, Cortland |
|||||
| 1994 |
Penny Hite, Fredonia |
|||||
| 1993 |
Steve Lucito, Cortland |
|||||
| 1992 |
Gary Truce, Binghamton Joe Fisher, Geneseo |
|||||
| 1991 |
Gary Truce, Binghamton |
|||||
| 1990 |
Joe Fisher, Geneseo |
|||||
| 1989 |
Adrean Zoschke, Fredonia |
|||||
| 1988 | Adrean Zoschke, Fredonia | |||||
| 1987 |
Ron White, Albany |
|||||
| 1986 | Adrean Zoschke, Fredonia | |||||
| 1985 |
Laura Crain, Cortland |
|||||
| 1984 |
Don Torok, Geneseo |
|||||
| 1983 | ||||||
| 1982 | ||||||
| 1981 |